Essential Guide of Vehicle Hard-Shell Carriers – March 2021 Edition

Looking to find the best Vehicle Hard-Shell Carriers?

We researched 26 Vehicle Hard-Shell Carriers, tested 20, and we have done 10 hours of research. The best Vehicle Hard-Shell Carriers doesn’t have to be complicated to be great. Our first pick is exactly that. No more, no less. It also costs less than any other products we tested.

The best

No. 1
Thule Pulse Rooftop Cargo Box, Medium , Black
  • Durable and rugged textured ABS material is long-lasting and helps protects contents during transit
  • Fast and secure fitting using only one hand due to Fast Grip quick-mount system that assembles in moments
  • Passenger-side opening for easier loading and unloading. Max length of skis - 155 centimetre
  • Central Locking system provides maximum safety. The grip-friendly Thule Comfort key can only be removed if all locking points are securely closed
  • External dimensions 67 x 35 x 16 inch
  • Internal dimensions 61 x 33 x 14 inch
  • Load capacity snowboards 3-5

Intro

Here’s your guide to choosing the best Vehicle Hard-Shell Carriers. As there is a great number of models with varying prices, you may find it difficult to figure out which one is right for you. For this reason, we decided to make a top 10 of the Vehicle Hard-Shell Carriers of different brands and prices based on the best value for money. This ranking was created to help you find the best Vehicle Hard-Shell Carriers depending on your needs and budgets. Our selection criteria are provided to give you a complete picture of the items offered. Get ready to find the Vehicle Hard-Shell Carriers that’s right for you!

Our picks

No. 1
Thule Pulse Rooftop Cargo Box, Medium , Black
  • Durable and rugged textured ABS material is long-lasting and helps protects contents during transit
  • Fast and secure fitting using only one hand due to Fast Grip quick-mount system that assembles in moments
  • Passenger-side opening for easier loading and unloading. Max length of skis - 155 centimetre
  • Central Locking system provides maximum safety. The grip-friendly Thule Comfort key can only be removed if all locking points are securely closed
  • External dimensions 67 x 35 x 16 inch
  • Internal dimensions 61 x 33 x 14 inch
  • Load capacity snowboards 3-5
No. 2
JEGS Rooftop Cargo Carrier | Hard Car Top Large Luggage Box | Waterproof Storage | Heavy Duty Solid Case | Made in USA | 18 Cubic Ft. | 100 Lb. Capacity | Zero Tool Easy Assembly | Aerodynamic Design
  • SECURE & PROTECT YOUR GEAR in this 18 cubic ft. HDPE plastic hard shell car top cargo carrier; high-capacity interior dimensions 57 L x 38 1/2 W x 17 3/4 H inches; aerodynamic design for fuel efficiency
  • WATERPROOF STORAGE FOR YOUR LUGGAGE with a four corner locking system, front latch, and weather-tight seal for ultimate car rooftop protection and security
  • EASY & CONVENIENT LOADING AND UNLOADING from either side of the car make for smooth travel and hassle-free storage
  • NO TOOLS REQUIRED, EASY ASSEMBLY AND INSTALLATION. All mounting hardware and simple instructions are included to get you safely on the road quickly
  • MADE IN USA, LIMITED LIFETIME GUARANTEE. The JEGS Rooftop Cargo Carrier’s high-quality construction and performance give you peace of mind
No. 3
Thule Force XT Rooftop Cargo Box, X-Large
  • Your purchase includes One Thule Force XT Rooftop X-Large Cargo Box in Black color
  • Cargo Box dimensions – 74.75" L x 24.75" W x 16.75" H | Inside dimensions – 70.5” L x 20.5” W x 14.75” H| Product weight – 32 pounds | Max carry weight – 165 pounds
  • Designed to fit a wide range of vehicles (compatible with most factory and aftermarket roof racks)
  • Tool-free, quick-mount system "clicks" When roof box is secure and properly mounted. Dual-side opening for easy access to all areas of the box, from either side of the vehicle
  • Narrow design leaves space for other gear such as bikes, kayaks, skis, and more while providing 11 cubic feet of additional packing space

Why you should trust us

This guide represents more than 10 years of experience in researching, testing, and writing about many subject. Our people are experts in all of their fields.
We alors spent 10 hours reading any article we could find on the internet and all the customer reviews at various retailer sites such as those of Amazon, Home Depot or Wallmart. We found many website that was a valuable resource with involved buying guides and detailed Vehicle Hard-Shell Carriers information.
As for me, I’m very familiar with the Vehicle Hard-Shell Carriers since I got it from 4 years.

Top 10

No. 1
Thule Pulse Rooftop Cargo Box, Medium , Black
  • Durable and rugged textured ABS material is long-lasting and helps protects contents during transit
  • Fast and secure fitting using only one hand due to Fast Grip quick-mount system that assembles in moments
  • Passenger-side opening for easier loading and unloading. Max length of skis - 155 centimetre
  • Central Locking system provides maximum safety. The grip-friendly Thule Comfort key can only be removed if all locking points are securely closed
  • External dimensions 67 x 35 x 16 inch
  • Internal dimensions 61 x 33 x 14 inch
  • Load capacity snowboards 3-5
No. 2
JEGS Rooftop Cargo Carrier | Hard Car Top Large Luggage Box | Waterproof Storage | Heavy Duty Solid Case | Made in USA | 18 Cubic Ft. | 100 Lb. Capacity | Zero Tool Easy Assembly | Aerodynamic Design
  • SECURE & PROTECT YOUR GEAR in this 18 cubic ft. HDPE plastic hard shell car top cargo carrier; high-capacity interior dimensions 57 L x 38 1/2 W x 17 3/4 H inches; aerodynamic design for fuel efficiency
  • WATERPROOF STORAGE FOR YOUR LUGGAGE with a four corner locking system, front latch, and weather-tight seal for ultimate car rooftop protection and security
  • EASY & CONVENIENT LOADING AND UNLOADING from either side of the car make for smooth travel and hassle-free storage
  • NO TOOLS REQUIRED, EASY ASSEMBLY AND INSTALLATION. All mounting hardware and simple instructions are included to get you safely on the road quickly
  • MADE IN USA, LIMITED LIFETIME GUARANTEE. The JEGS Rooftop Cargo Carrier’s high-quality construction and performance give you peace of mind
No. 3
Thule Force XT Rooftop Cargo Box, X-Large
  • Your purchase includes One Thule Force XT Rooftop X-Large Cargo Box in Black color
  • Cargo Box dimensions – 74.75" L x 24.75" W x 16.75" H | Inside dimensions – 70.5” L x 20.5” W x 14.75” H| Product weight – 32 pounds | Max carry weight – 165 pounds
  • Designed to fit a wide range of vehicles (compatible with most factory and aftermarket roof racks)
  • Tool-free, quick-mount system "clicks" When roof box is secure and properly mounted. Dual-side opening for easy access to all areas of the box, from either side of the vehicle
  • Narrow design leaves space for other gear such as bikes, kayaks, skis, and more while providing 11 cubic feet of additional packing space
SaleNo. 4
Vetoos 21 Cubic Feet Car Rooftop Cargo Carrier Bag, Soft Roof Top Luggage Bag for All Vechicles SUV with/Without Racks - Waterproof Zip, Anti-Tear 700D PVC, with Storage Bag & Anti-Slip Mat
  • 【OVERSIZED 21 CUBIC FEET】Massive 21 cubic feet (L52" x W39.5" x H17.5") of space can easily hold all luggage of a family of 5-6. Most other roof cargo carriers are small and there is not enough room to accommodate everything you need.
  • 【HIGH DENSITY 700D PVC】Features triple-layer high density 700D PVC fabric. This material is 1.5 times stronger than 500D PVC fabric, which most other rooftop bags adopts and can easily rip. The coated surface can effectively protect your luggage against rain, grit, snow, wind and sun on the road.
  • 【UPGRADED WATERPROOF ZIP】While other rooftop carrier bags let in water through the normal zipper, we've upgraded it to a waterproof zipper and fitted it with a widened 4.7" zipper flap that helps keep your items 100% dry.
  • 【REINFORCED STRAP SEAM】We notice that the straps of other cargo bags can easily rip from the seam, so we doubly reinforced the strap seam. And all seams of this cargo bag are heat welded and stitched to ensure they are watertight.
  • 【FIT ALL CARS】Whether your car is with roof rack or not, the 4 door hooks and 8 strong straps can always secure your roof top carrier bag. In addition, the equipped anti-slip mat can keep the cargo bag stay in place even in high speed road, and protect your car roof from scratches and damage.
No. 5
adakiit Car Roof Bag Cargo Carrier, 20 Cubic Feet Waterproof Rooftop Luggage Bag Vehicle Softshell Carriers with 8 Reinforced Straps and Storage Carrying Bag for All Vehicle with/Without Rack
  • WATERPROOF: This premium quality car top bag is made of military grade materials with waterproof dual seam technology and water repellent double coating. It adopts a genuine waterproof zipper, used in extreme weather!
  • X- LARGE SIZE: Our roof bag was designed to solve the problem of limited storage space in the car. 20 cubic feet rooftop cargo bag allows you to hold 4-6 suitcases, travel luggage case, tents, sleeping bags and more. Free up inside vehicle space for more comfortable on the way.
  • MOST SAFE DESIGN: For security reasons, we use 8 reinforced adjustable straps to keep the cargo carrier in place. In addition, equipped even in high speed road or bump road, no slip, no scratch to your car.
  • WORKS WITH or WITHOUT ROOF RACK: Use this car roof top luggage carrier with any sized car or SUV. It can be quickly and easily installed in minutes whether your vehicle has a rack installed or not.
  • NOTE: All seams are heat welded and stitched to ensure they are watertight. that your luggage will stay safe and protected in all weather conditions during your travels. But please note that it's not 100% waterproof under rainstorm weather.
No. 6
Goplus Cargo Box, Waterproof Rooftop Cargo Carrier, Heavy Duty Roof Storage Box, 14 Cubic Feet (White)
  • Perfect for Road Trip---Take the cargo box to the park, the beach, the sports field, or any place you need to store. Works on all vehicles with rack, suitable for cars, vans, SUVs, etc. Sleek aerodynamic design to reduce drag and has less noise.
  • 14 Cubic Feet of Cargo Space---With the large capacity, the roof cargo box can help you securely carry 14 cubic feet worth of essentials, can increase vehicle cargo space without impeding on passenger comfort, more capacity, more pleasure!
  • Robust and Security Design---The roof cargo box is designed to withstand heavy use in different types of weather conditions. The metal lid stiffeners at the bottom makes the roof box more stable and safer. With the double-lock design for protecting your valuables. 【Note】This product is suitable for vehicles with rack (the width of the luggage rack is adjusted to between 16.1 inches and 24.8 inches, and the width of the roof crossbar is less than 3.1 inches).
  • High Quality Material---The roof box is manufactured from sturdy ABS and PC material for long-lasting use, able to protect your valuables from exposure to the elements and can load 165 lbs capacity, suitable for round, square, factory and most aerodynamic bars.
  • Easy to Install---The Goplus roof box equipped with 4 quick connect anchors for easy install and super latch security ensures your lid secure to its base, and your gear is safe. Dual-sided opening for easy access on either side of your vehicle to increased efficiency and convenience.
No. 7
Fivklemnz Car Roof Bag Cargo Carrier, 15 Cubic Feet Waterproof Rooftop Cargo Carrier with Anti-Slip Mat + 8 Reinforced Straps + 4 Door Hooks Suitable for All Vehicle with/Without Rack
  • 【Most Safe Design】: For security reasons, we use 8 reinforced adjustable straps to keep the cargo carrier in place. In addition, equipped with free anti-slip mat to keep the cargo bag stay in place even in high speed road or bump road, no slip, no scratch to your car.
  • 【Large Storage Space】: Fivklemnz roof bag was designed to solve the problem of limited storage space in the car. 15 cubic feet rooftop cargo bag allows you to hold 4-6 suitcases, travel luggage case, tents, sleeping bags and more. Free up inside vehicle space for more comfortable on the way.
  • 【Easy to Install】:Fivklemnz rooftop cargo carrier fits for any car, truck, or SUV. If there is not roof side rails on your car, it can be quickly and easily installed to roof rack in minutes with 4 door hooks.
  • 【100% Waterproof】: Made of 600D Oxford cloth, Fivklemnz roof bag adopts a genuine waterproof zipper, used in extreme weather and is protected with a double flap. All seams are heat welded and stitched to ensure they are watertight. 100% waterproof and rainproof under extreme weather.
  • 【100% Refund or Replacement】:7x24 online customer support, ask us anything at any time. Backed by 30 days money-back guarantee and 12 months limited warranty.
No. 8
JEGS Rooftop Cargo Carrier | Hard Car Top Small Luggage Box | Waterproof Storage | Heavy Duty Solid Case | Made in USA | 10 Cubic Ft. | 110 Lb. Capacity | Zero Tool Easy Assembly | Aerodynamic Design
  • SECURE & PROTECT YOUR GEAR in this 10 cubic ft. HDPE plastic hard shell car top cargo carrier; high-capacity interior dimensions 46 1/2 L x 30 1/2 W x 17 1/2 H inches; aerodynamic design for fuel efficiency
  • WATERPROOF STORAGE FOR YOUR LUGGAGE with a four corner locking system, front latch, and weather-tight seal for ultimate car rooftop protection and security
  • EASY & CONVENIENT LOADING AND UNLOADING from either side of the car make for smooth travel and hassle-free storage
  • NO TOOLS REQUIRED, EASY ASSEMBLY AND INSTALLATION. All mounting hardware and simple instructions are included to get you safely on the road quickly
  • MADE IN USA, LIMITED LIFETIME GUARANTEE. The JEGS Rooftop Cargo Carrier’s high-quality construction and performance give you peace of mind
No. 9
DNA MOTORING PT-ZTL-8166-BK Car Roof Top Mount Travel Storage Box Luggage Carrier w/Lock with Cross Bars Only,Black
  • Heavy Duty ABS Plastic Construction
  • Overall Dimensions: 53" L x 34" W x 15" H
  • Opens to 14" Wide to Store Bulky Items
  • Capacity: 10 cu. ft.
  • Opens from the Side and Stays Open Til you Close It
SaleNo. 10
Adakiit Car Roof Bag Cargo Carrier, 20 Cubic Feet Waterproof Rooftop Luggage Bag Vehicle Softshell Carriers with 8 Reinforced Straps and Storage Carrying Bag for All Vehicle with/Without Rack
  • Super Waterproof - This cargo roof carrier is Crafted from rubber laminated nylon,to protect your gear and luggage from rain and dust on the road. Make sure you wrap it so ur things don’t get wet Making sure the flap for the zipper, is facing the rear of the vehicle.
  • Easy to Install & Use - The installation of the roof top storage bag is simple.Thanks to the foldable material, 6 built-in tie straps and 6 extra straps, our car top carrier attaches in only a matter of minutes,also easily to fold the entire roof bag inside the duffle bag when not in use.
  • High Capacity & Easy Store - The cargo bag is very roomy that could fit a lot.The roof bag overall size is 51''x39''x17'', Carry 20 cubic feet worth of essentials,can increase vehicle cargo space without impeding on passenger comfort,more capacity, more pleasure! Having this room up top is certainly great for family travel and trips.
  • Sturdy & Security - Our car top carrier made from high-quality material, no toxic or harmful chemicals used.With 6 extra Strong, wide straps and 2 long(3 meters) straps which can across the whole bag to ensure that everything stays in place even on rough and bumpy road.Very secure once strapped on the top rail.
  • Perfect for Trave/Trip - Take the cargo bag to the park, the beach, the sports field, or any place you need to be storaged. Works on ALL vehicles with rack,suitable for cars, vans, SUVs,etc.

How we tested

We search all the field to find the best Vehicle Hard-Shell Carriers and all the type for it and get the best alternatives, priced decently, and easy to use. After that we tested all the main parameters we use : These things can separate the great Vehicle Hard-Shell Carriers from the good.

  • Easy To use
  • Options
  • Quality
  • Longevity

How we picked

We search for all the field to find the best Vehicle Hard-Shell Carriers and all the type for it and get the best alternatives, priced decently, and easy to use.
The main parameters we use : These things can separate the bad Vehicle Hard-Shell Carriers from the good.

  • Price
  • Easy To use
  • Customer reviews
  • Quality
  • Longevity
  • Dimensions

Current Offers

SaleNo. 1
Vetoos 21 Cubic Feet Car Rooftop Cargo Carrier Bag, Soft Roof Top Luggage Bag for All Vechicles SUV with/Without Racks - Waterproof Zip, Anti-Tear 700D PVC, with Storage Bag & Anti-Slip Mat
  • 【OVERSIZED 21 CUBIC FEET】Massive 21 cubic feet (L52" x W39.5" x H17.5") of space can easily hold all luggage of a family of 5-6. Most other roof cargo carriers are small and there is not enough room to accommodate everything you need.
  • 【HIGH DENSITY 700D PVC】Features triple-layer high density 700D PVC fabric. This material is 1.5 times stronger than 500D PVC fabric, which most other rooftop bags adopts and can easily rip. The coated surface can effectively protect your luggage against rain, grit, snow, wind and sun on the road.
  • 【UPGRADED WATERPROOF ZIP】While other rooftop carrier bags let in water through the normal zipper, we've upgraded it to a waterproof zipper and fitted it with a widened 4.7" zipper flap that helps keep your items 100% dry.
  • 【REINFORCED STRAP SEAM】We notice that the straps of other cargo bags can easily rip from the seam, so we doubly reinforced the strap seam. And all seams of this cargo bag are heat welded and stitched to ensure they are watertight.
  • 【FIT ALL CARS】Whether your car is with roof rack or not, the 4 door hooks and 8 strong straps can always secure your roof top carrier bag. In addition, the equipped anti-slip mat can keep the cargo bag stay in place even in high speed road, and protect your car roof from scratches and damage.
SaleNo. 2
Adakiit Car Roof Bag Cargo Carrier, 20 Cubic Feet Waterproof Rooftop Luggage Bag Vehicle Softshell Carriers with 8 Reinforced Straps and Storage Carrying Bag for All Vehicle with/Without Rack
  • Super Waterproof - This cargo roof carrier is Crafted from rubber laminated nylon,to protect your gear and luggage from rain and dust on the road. Make sure you wrap it so ur things don’t get wet Making sure the flap for the zipper, is facing the rear of the vehicle.
  • Easy to Install & Use - The installation of the roof top storage bag is simple.Thanks to the foldable material, 6 built-in tie straps and 6 extra straps, our car top carrier attaches in only a matter of minutes,also easily to fold the entire roof bag inside the duffle bag when not in use.
  • High Capacity & Easy Store - The cargo bag is very roomy that could fit a lot.The roof bag overall size is 51''x39''x17'', Carry 20 cubic feet worth of essentials,can increase vehicle cargo space without impeding on passenger comfort,more capacity, more pleasure! Having this room up top is certainly great for family travel and trips.
  • Sturdy & Security - Our car top carrier made from high-quality material, no toxic or harmful chemicals used.With 6 extra Strong, wide straps and 2 long(3 meters) straps which can across the whole bag to ensure that everything stays in place even on rough and bumpy road.Very secure once strapped on the top rail.
  • Perfect for Trave/Trip - Take the cargo bag to the park, the beach, the sports field, or any place you need to be storaged. Works on ALL vehicles with rack,suitable for cars, vans, SUVs,etc.
SaleNo. 3
Car Top Carrier Roof Bag | 15 or 20 Cubic ft + Protective Mat - for Cars with or Without Racks
  • ✅ Many car rack roof bags claim to be waterproof but aren’t. our roof top carrier waterproof bag is made of heavy-duty coated tarpaulin & fabric-guarded, coated zippers for 100% waterproof protection. your belongings stay just as you packed them.
  • ✅ Cheap Car Carriers Rooftop Bags fall apart & tear. our car luggage carrier roof bag is made of extra heavy-duty materials that withstand the road. Perfect car top carriers for vehicles with racks & car top carriers for vehicles without racks - amazing car rack system rack adapter
  • ✅ Roof Top Carrier Bags With Broken Zippers & Loose Straps Can Ruin Trips. We engineered every aspect of our dimensions recommended here car storage rooftop bag with attention to detail, so each feature works without a hitch. Easy to carry, it’s perfect for everyone.
  • ✅ Why Save A Few Bucks On A Cheap Car Roof Bag Just To Scratch Up Your Car’s Roof? Our bonus protection mat saves your expensive paint job where other car bags do more damage than they’re worth. Plus! Ours is angled for better wind resistance so you can ride safe not fearing it will tear off in a heavy wind.
  • ✅ Lasting trip after trip, our car storage rooftop bag makes adventure easy. Our mission at tool guards is to bring you road trip accessories & car camping accessories that provide the smoothest journey you’ve ever had or your money back! We offer a 2-year 100% money back guarantee.
SaleNo. 4
MIDABAO Car Top Carrier Roof Bag by Waterproof 1200-Denier Polyester Material - 100% Waterproof & Coated Zippers 20 Cubic ft - for Cars with or Without Racks
252 Reviews
MIDABAO Car Top Carrier Roof Bag by Waterproof 1200-Denier Polyester Material - 100% Waterproof & Coated Zippers 20 Cubic ft - for Cars with or Without Racks
  • 20 Cubic Feet - Carrying capacity - The whole point of the purchase us to provide additional cargo room, so it makes no point to buy one that is not big enough. the roof bag overall size is 51.1'' x 39'' x 17'', Carry 20 cubic feet. Larger than other brand.
  • Soft Car Top Carrier - There is no ”Best Soft Car Top Carrier”. Instead, the best one is the one that satisfies your specific needs.However, we provides the best all-around value and is likely to satisfy more consumers. We provides larger capacity ( 20 Cubic ), top PVC material, convenient design and more security.
  • Easy Mounting & Storage Design - Design with 6 short tie straps & 2 long straps, make it easy to attaches in only a matter of minutes. Our Carrier is purely malleable, more simple to store than the carrier with stiff inner-lining ( storage bag included ).
  • Waterproof - PVC Materials - The torrential downpour will test merely water resistant materials to their limit and likely result in damp or soaked contents. But our car top carrier is coated with PVC to aid in waterproofing ( inside and out ),NOT ONLY WATER RESISTANT like other brand.
  • 6 Tough Straps - More Security- Alongside carrying capacity, stability is arguably the most important factor in a car top carrier. We Provide 6pc wide straps & 2pc 3M straps. To some extent, the more straps used to fasten the carrier to the roof the better.
SaleNo. 5
RoofPax Car Roof Bag & Rooftop Cargo Carrier. 19 Cubic Feet. 100% Waterproof Excellent Military Quality Car Top Carrier. Heavy Duty RoofBag. Fits All Vehicle With/Without Rack. 4+2 Door Hooks Included
  • ✅ SAFETY COMES FIRST: RoofPax is the ONLY brand that produces its Car Roof Bag for maximum safety with 4+2 free door hooks (included), instead of using straps that go inside the car. Tying down any car top luggage involving straps going through the inside of the car is HIGHLY dangerous as they interfere with air bags in case they open and are illegal to use in some states. RoofPax is the safest and most secure Car Roof Cargo Bag on the market today.
  • ✅ MILITARY QUALITY WATERPROOF: This premium quality car top bag is made of military grade materials with waterproof dual seam technology and water repellent double coating. This roof bag features include a built-in protective mat and 10 elastic velcro strap restrainers to prevent strap flapping. Security features also include a heavy duty SBS zipper, 10 strong straps with NIFCO buckles and double strap covers with 8 Velcro stripes.
  • ✅ WORKS WITH or WITHOUT ROOF RACK: Use RoofPax car roof top luggage carrier with any sized car or SUV. It can be quickly and easily installed in minutes whether your vehicle has a rack installed or not.
  • ✅ X-LARGE SIZE: The dimensions of: L47.2" x W 35.4" x H 19.8" Provides 19 cubic feet of rooftop cargo storage so you will never run out of space for carrying all you need on your next car trip or adventure. The 19 cf RoofPax Bag can hold 4-6 suitcases and more, Pack all you want with the confidence that your luggage will stay safe and protected in all weather conditions during your travels.
  • ✅ LIFETIME WARRANTY on Zippers and Buckles for breakage or tear! Our customers' satisfaction, confidence and trust in our brand is our #1 top priority. If you are not 100% happy with your purchase, let us know so we can make it right by refunding or replacing your order. *Activation of warranty required on RoofPax website*

Conclusion

This guide is here to support you in your choice of Vehicle Hard-Shell Carriers and is regularly updated so that you can make an informed selection. Nowadays, it’s not that easy to know about each and every product that’s on the market. So we hope that this comparison was able to help you with choosing the best Vehicle Hard-Shell Carriers according to your criteria. Your comments are most welcome and they will help us improve the ranking.

Click to rate this post!
[Total: 0 Average: 0]

Last update on 2021-03-03 at 08:14 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API

Leave a Comment